In recent seasons, Broadway has seen a lot of musicals based on popular movies or revivals of classics, so when an unfamiliar story comes across, people are bound to take notice. Housed in the beautiful Walter Kerr Theatre, A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder, a new musical based on Roy Horniman's 1907 novel, Israel Rank: the Autobiography of a Criminal has something for everyone: comedy, romance, and as the title suggests, homicide.
A
Gentlman's Guide begins with an ensemble of mourners
dressed in black warning us that "those with weak constitutions" were
better off leaving. We then see an almost play-within-a-play; a smaller,
vaudeville-esque stage with lush curtains is the main focus as protagonist
Montague Navarro (Bryce Pinkham) narrates his tale. Monty finds out soon after
his mother's death that he is actually a part of the prestigious D'Ysquith
family, and is in fact ninth in line to be the Earl of Highhurst. In order to
win the attention of the beautiful (yet snobbish) Sibella (Lisa O'Hare), Monty
devises a scheme to “off” the remaining D'Ysquiths and claim the title of Earl,
and even catches himself falling for the demure Phoebe D'Ysquith (Lauren
Worsham). The action is shown in a series of vignettes , helping to create the
play within a play motif.
Credited as "The
D'Ysquith Family," Jefferson Mays makes an impressive performance as all eight
victims. His distinctions between each character were so remarkable, it takes a
few deaths to even realize they're all him. From the effervescently effeminate
Henry D'Ysquith to the outrageous drag of Lady Hyacinth D'Ysquith, Mays'
performance needs to be seen. The entire cast, ranging from seasoned veterans
and those making Broadway debuts, make up an ensemble that is extremely strong
despite its small size. Alexander
Dodge's artfully crafted set, along with Aaron Rhyne's striking projection
design steal the show. And although at times Robert L Freedman and Steven
Lutvak's score felt like it was somewhat repetitive, audiences walk away
humming tunes like "Why Are All the D'Ysquiths Dying?" and
"Better With a Man."
Entering the
performance, based on advertising and even from the impression of the opening
number, I was expecting a very dark, macabre musical. However despite the
warning, those with "weak constitutions" needn't fear: think less Sweeney Todd and more Thoroughly Modern Millie with a taste
for blood. A Gentleman's Guide to Love
and Murder could be, dare I say, perfect for a night out with the family:
appropriate enough for tween audiences with the right amount of adult themes. It
is a delightfully bloody tale that should be taken notice of.
A
Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder opened on November 17
and currently plays at the Walter Kerr Theatre.
Photos By: Joan Marcus
Review By: Kelcie Kosberg
Photos By: Joan Marcus
Review By: Kelcie Kosberg